Icheoku does not carry water for Chief Bode George and our disdain for his then boss, Olusegun Obasanjo and aversion to corruption is of general knowledge. But what we are against is using someone of his personality as a sacrificial lamb to show a pretended appetite to fight corruption by the north controlled EFCC, Ministry of Justice and the Presidency? The heat is on them after Hillary Clinton's umbrage, to prove that Nuhu Ribadu was not removed simply because of his 'effectiveness and that he was over-reaching into forbidden territory' but that Madam Farida is as well competent? If Bode George had corruptly enriched himself with the 85 billion naira sum in question, Icheoku would have called for his being tied at a stake and with a barrage of lead, dispatched to the world hereafter. So the question is why would Bode George be imprisoned for just 'doing the right thing but following a wrong procedure;' when so many northerners, looters of the national treasury are oppressively holding sway in the country with wealth stolen from the national treasury with impunity and suffered no consequence as a result? Who have held Ibrahim Badamosi Babangida accountable for all that he took from the Nigerian coffers particularly the $12 billion Gulf war oil windfall? Who has held Abdulsalam Abubakar accountable for the 16 billion naira power supply contract which he failed, refused or neglected to execute after collecting 91.1% of the contract sum as mobilization fees thereto? Who held Muhammadu Buhari accountable for the $2.8 billion missing oil money which he helped himself with when he was NNPC chairman under Olusegun Obasanjo's first missionary journey to Nigeria's seat of power at Dodan Barracks? Who has held Atiku Abubakar accountable for all that he stole while at Nigerian customs and excise and as vice president of Nigeria? Who held Senator Jubril Aminu accountable for the $12 million dollars SIEMENS bribery scandal? What about Olusola Saraki and FESTAC 77 and the unbridled looting that was witnessed then purchasing buses and coaches at hyper-inflated prices? Should we talk about NPN's Umaru Dikko and the scandalous rice contracts he embarked on as Transport Minister during Shehu Shagari's lacklustre government of yore? Barkin Zuwo's bedroom banking of state's money is still fresh in memory? How about the sugar merchant Aliko Dangote and the list of other northerners bilking Nigeria goes on and on ad infinitum! And if that was not already enough pilfering, recall that Nigeria has recieved as income an amount in excess of $700 billion dollars since coming of age in 1960 and that northerners has been in charge for more than 39 of Nigeria's 49 years of existence, so where is the money, Nigerians? So why Chief Bode George? The gist of the matter is that all Nigerian public officials have sinned and fallen short of glory; so it does not make sense to just single out Chief Bode George under the circumstances just because some uncircumcised northerners said so! Admitted that some apologists will refer Icheoku to the last name of the judge who convicted the NPA6 to say it does not sound northern; but to this group we say, the north have perfected playing southerners against one another. But who the heck are these northerners that preach holier than thou, when their only job or clearly defined business/means of livelihood is fleecing and scheming Nigerian coffers; either as ten per-centers or brazenly dipping their filthy hands inside the coffers of the Nigerian treasury? Chief Bode George is corrupt and so what; at least that was not the charge for which he was tried and now stands convicted? Is he the first or only corrupt person in Nigeria and why not start with the north whose penchant for stealing from the government in Nigeria is widely acknowledged? If really Chief Bode George is corrupt and 'embezzled' 85 billion naira, why only the two years imprisonment slap on the wrist sentence? Where in such pitiable sentence lies the deterrence? Where is the intended statement that corruption is frowned at, being made by such conviction and punishment? What amount was he asked to refund back to the government as restitution? How many of his assets were confiscated or seized or asked to be forfeited? In short, the sentence does not fit well or support a crime 'committed' by Chief Bode George and Icheoku encourages an appeal under the circumstances. In a more advanced and law-abiding country, where deterrence is always the objective of judicial punishment, a person who messed with 85 billion naira and was convicted on 47 counts out of 63 counts charges, will not just receive a mere two years imprisonment? No, such sentence as was handed down here is apologetically infinitesimal and proves there was more than met the eyes. What about two years each for every billion naira resulting to a total of 170 years? How about two years for each count resulting to 94 years? What about ten years for each one billion resulting to 850 years behind bars? Talk of deterrence and the United States of America proudly comes to mind of a place where criminals often receive 1000 years imprisonment; and politicians alike such as the former Louisiana governor who is serving 400 years imprisonment for embezzling $400,000 dollars? Also remember the imprisoned Republican Congressman Duke Cunningham of Southern California who had everything with his name on it or some semblance of his ownership taken from him and auctioned off; from a Rolls-Royce to floor carpets just to make reparation for his corrupt enrichment? Such is what we are talking about and which Icheoku envisages for a Nigeria that is serious with fighting corruption and punishing corrupt public officials who misuse what is trusted in their care by reason of their office. If Chief Bode George fretted away 85 billion naira, then justice demands that he at least get one year for each billion which would have put his prison sentence to at least 85 years in addition to an earth-scorching restitution order, with a lien of forfeiture levied on anything bearing his name or any close resemblance. Whatever it takes, just make that statement that Nigeria is tired and cannot continue to aid and abet corruption within the system. May be 85 life sentences or possibly 850 years would have been a preferred sentence to compensate for the 85 billion naira but surely not two sorry years? But is the proverbial half bread better than none true in this case of Chief Bode George, a yesterday's man of power now convicted and gone to prison? Icheoku does not buy into the argument that the gist of the conviction lies in its symbolism and that it far outweighs the severity of any sentence that would have been otherwise imposed under the circumstance? That it says so much for a previously untouchable Nigerian to now forever carry, barring a successful appeal, the toga of a convicted criminal? That Chief Bode George being otherwise denuded and defrocked is worth more psychologically, than his thousand years behind bars? Which ever side of the divide you find yourself, our position is that majority of past and present Nigerian leaders are very corrupt and severally corruptly over-enriched themselves; that a more soul-searching introspective steps ought to be taken to rout out the endemic and entrenched corruption in Nigeria. It has to be total and complete covering all past people in leadership positions especially in Northern Nigeria! In his judgment convicting Chief Bode George and co, Justice Olubunmi Oyewole said: "When public office is abused, the entire populace is assaulted. This must not be condoned or treated with kid gloves. If the quality of service in our public life is to be altered to the appreciable standard of the civilised world, the right deterrent should be given. For the right deterrent to be served, therefore, sufficient firmness must be demonstrated." Icheoku says, what a complete hogwash that this judge raised his hand like a giant only to flop it like a weakling midget. He was high in pontification and sounding the right tone, only to chicken out in handing out his jelly-sentence of two and half years? Why raise the hopes of millions that finally, a king who does not know Joseph has ascended the throne and called for rendering of account by Chief Bode George and co, only to just slap their wrists with such a baby-sentence? Icheoku asks this Justice Oyewole, where in his two and half years prison sentence was his suggested "not treat this matter with kids gloves" factored in? Was two years the "right deterrent" for a 85 billion Naira scam-contracts? Icheoku concludes that Justice Olubunmi Oyewole did not show any firmness with his two and half years prison sentence for Chief Bode George and co; which we believe is sure to be overturned on appeal for being too light a sentence or better still for not being meritorious?
Thursday, October 29, 2009
AS BODE GEORGE REPORTS TO KIRIKIRI, ANY LESSONS LEARNED?
Icheoku have for so long, resisted the temptation to join the lynch-mob, calling for the head of Chief Olabode Ibiyinka George over his 'dereliction of duty' while overseeing the affairs of the Nigerian Ports Authority as its chairman from 2001 to 2003? Total tab involved is said to be about 85 billion naira? He was not accused of stealing the sum or misappropriate it for himself; no, his crime was 'by-passing the Hausa-Fulani man in charge of the Ministry of Transportation to award such a huge contract?' Really? So their thinking was, 'how dare you develop such an independent-streak and audacity not to get a clearance from us, the Hausa-Fulani overlords of Nigeria before discharging the duties of your office? Chief Bode George is a southerner, from Yoruba west; so what gave him the impetus to act without first checking with the feudalistic north, before awarding contracts of such amount? This is the crux of the matter, the big deal for which he was indicted and now sentenced?
Continuing the judge said, "The penalty for disobedience to lawful order is a maximum of one year imprisonment. I hereby sentence all the defendants to six months imprisonment ... and to two years for each of the abuse of office convicted counts of contract splitting and inflation." Icheoku queries, why did the judge make his order to run concurrently instead of consecutively, if he is serious about providing deterrence? Who in corrupt Nigeria would not readily head to prison for two and half years after such a 'massive loot', if that is all it takes to keep such spoils of corruption; after-all in Nigerian prison you can buy yourself any amount of freedom including conjugal visits with your spouse or a paid service-provider, once the right amount exchanges hands? Conviction on 47 counts for just two and half years rather sounds as ridiculous as it was too demeaning to the psyche of that Nigerian that strives to be upright and do good? Also why did the judge not make the sentence in addition to payment of fine; after-all the objective is to deter future abuse? If they are being sentenced for abuse of office and fraud, is it not the proper thing to do to at the same token, deny them the spoils of such abuse? So where is the restitution order, Mr. Justice Oyewole?
Conviction on 47 out of 63-count charge of conspiracy, disobedience to lawful order, inflation of contracts and contracts splitting just received two and half years imprisonment? Tell it to the marines! It is also instructive to note that this was one of the fastest trial proceeding ever recorded in a Nigerian court, notorious for its frustrating judicial logjam, which is sometimes perpetrated by conniving lawyers to wilfully and purposely obstruct and delay justice for the opposing side? Just under one year, from October 29, 2008 to October 26, 2009 bearing in mind that the framed suspects in Pa Rewane's 1995 murder, are still languishing in prison ever since, awaiting indictment which seems not to be coming and five of them are known to have so far died in the prison custody? So what happened to accelerate Chief Bode George's trial and conviction; or are the north trying to land the big fish, Olusegun Obasanjo as recently predicted by El-Rufai?
Since the sentence will run concurrently, each man will spend two and a half years in prison instead of at least the more reasonable one hundred and seventeen and a half years, unless an appellate court overturns Justice Oyewole's verdict. Icheoku reiterates that the six convicted men were not accused of making any profit or unjustly enriching themselves by their action at the ports authority; no, they were merely accused of not following bureaucratic orders? Could this probably explain the two and half years sentences given to each of them, which will probably be overturned on appeal for lack of merit? Icheoku queries, since when has disobedience to ordinary administrative authority or bureaucratic orders, which did not result to any financial crimes, amount to a criminally prosecutable offence? What these convicts allegedly did was simply exceed their authority but they did not flagrantly enrich themselves or profit from whatever it was they did? So where lies the crime except in the wombs of time, when the appellate court will uphold their convictions or just throw the damn thing away as ridiculous and laughable? But until the later happens Chief Olabode Ibiyinka George stands a convicted criminal of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (CCFRN)! What an award to get in one's golden years! It will be recalled that Chief Bode George was chairman of the Board of Directors of the Nigerian Ports Authority (NPA) from 2001 to 2003 and also Director-General of the then Yar'Adua-Jonathan Presidential Campaign Organisation in 2007. He was also the former South West National Deputy Chairman of the ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDP).
Now as he sits in Kirirkiri maximum prison in Lagos awaiting the outcome of his appeal, whether the stigma of a convict stays with him will depend on the its outcome, otherwise what a way to finish a career that saw him in charge of a naval command as well as a post retirement good run in politics, including a public office! What a sorry lesson in the ephemeral and fleeting nature of power, that this former governor of Ondo State, former naval commodore, a PDP chieftain and former chairman of Nigeria Ports Authority now sits in prison, a convicted felon?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
BODE GEORGE: From Garrison Commander To Prisoner
ReplyDeleteWritten by By Chibuzo Ukaibe, Abuja
Saturday, 31 October 2009 06:39
It is a classical case of degradation, one that is akin to the popular saying that someone has fallen from grace to grass. Chief Bode George, a prominent Nigerian, one of the feared "garrison commanders" of the ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), when that party walked the un-democratic path as a garrison party, the only one in the world, second only to perhaps the Communist parties in China and the then Soviet Union in the days when communist dictatorship held sway, is now in jail.
Aside his garrison position, Bode George was a prominent member of former President Obasanjo's inner circle. This retired naval officer, who held the enviable position of a commodore, is used to giving orders and being obeyed.
Under his kinsman, Olusegun Obasanjo, he was very well placed to do that. He was even a deputy vice chairman (South) of the party, in which position he ensured that the South West was properly brought into the PDP fold at the national level with the wholesale routing of the Alliance for Democracy (AD) governors, who held sway in the South West between 1998 and 2003.
Today, however, Chief Bode George, who once in a joyous and boisterous mood, referred to himself, as a Lagos boy, has, fallen from his Olympian Heights. Most probably from being a glamorous, wealthy and lucky Lagos boy, this former military governor of Ondo State, all things being equal, would likely serve a two and half year sentence in a prison in Lagos, or wherever else that might please the prison authorities.
The question at this juncture is how did Bode George get into such a mess? What is or are the factors that culminated in his present degradation?
Journey to Infamy
The journey to infamy of this favoured PDP stalwart began in 2001 following his appointment as chairman of the Board of the lucrative Nigeria Ports Authority (NPA).
The Nigeria Ports Authority is a rich parastatal, a major revenue earner for the federal government. The parastatal is so solvent that anyhow, a Chief executive, or a chairman of Board can do good business. Usually, those given jobs at the NPA are the favoured of the party and those in power who are expected to deliver or give back to the party when the time comes. These categories of party men are influential and close to the corridors of power.
Thus, in a way, they are people who are a law unto themselves, fearing no man except the president, who normally makes the appointment. Such a person or persons, usually knows how to use power to exploit situations and Chief Bode George fitted the bill very well.
The former deputy chairman (South) of the ruling party was jailed alongside his friends and collaborators, who in their own right are favoured and over-indulged personages. They are former NPA managing director, Aminu Dabo, Captain Olusegun Abidoye, Alhaji Abdullahi Aminu Tafida, Alhaji Zamna Maidaribe and Alhaji Sule Aliyu.
Their offences were those of abuse of office which attracted a seven-count charge, and willful disobedience to lawful authority. The trial judge, Justice Oyewole, found the accused persons culpable of contract splitting, abuse of office and disobedience of lawful authority. They were however acquitted of the offence to contract inflation.
According to the charges, Chief Bode George and the former Board members were first arraigned on August 9, 2008 before the Lagos State High court on a 163-count charge by the EFCC. Later, the anti-graft agency filed fresh charges against them on the 24th of October, 2008.
The offence of the Board members is that on June 6, 2003, they conspired to inflate the contract price for the rehabilitation of the accidented Kalmar Container Handler, from 215,555.52 euros to 269,965.71 euros. They were also alleged to have inflated the cost of contracts awarded to Dateks Limited for the replacement and installation of six 11KZA high tension panels with accessories at substation 'C' Tin Can Island Port, Lagos from 310,500.40 euros to 345,925.00 euros. There were other allegations of impropriety that bordered on how contracts were awarded and shared by the NPA Board under Chief George.
ReplyDeleteIt would be recalled that were it not for lack of respect for the rule of law and due process by the former civilian government of President Olusegun Obasanjo, perhaps Chief George and his associates would have been convicted long ago and would have finished their terms by now. However, the former president saved the group when he brushed aside the EFCC report that indicted these people.
Judgement Hailed
It is therefore no surprise that the former EFCC boss, Nuhu Ribadu, feeling vindicated, was the first to hail the judgement. According to Ribadu, the conviction marked a great reference point in the investigation, prosecution and trial of corruption cases in Nigeria. He went on: "I salute the courage and intellect of the judge, who has demonstrated over time that he is an exemplary reference in the fight against corruption, and for a true definition of the rule of law in the country.' In this connection, said Ribadu, "We must all salute the long and sustained investigation leading to the indictment of Bode George in 2005."
Other reactions came from the All Nigeria Peoples Party (ANPP) which, while applauding the judgement as a victory for the nation and its judiciary, lamented that the sentence was too small for an offence of such magnitude.
According to Emma Eneukwu, the party's national publicity secretary, "Our argument is that two years is too small for an offence of such magnitude."
He further added that the ruling is liberation from the strangulation by the authoritarian government led by the PDP. "The recent performance of the judiciary has been impressive and by this, our democracy would be adequately defended. "He added that the judgement delivered by the an Ikeja High Court, which jailed Olabode George and five others, most of whom are PDP chieftains, over charges involving several billions, was testimony to the fact that no-one is above the law.
He stressed that the verdict will spark off the much needed exposure of atrocities committed by other 'big fishes' yet to be tried. "At least the judiciary has rekindled the hope of the common man and this goes to prove that some top government officials are corrupt in their minds, as they misuse public offices which they occupy and they are bent on swindling our economy and subjecting millions of people to abject poverty and torture," he said.
Corroborating the ANPP spokesman, the Transition Monitoring Group (TMG) stated that the jailing of Bode George is the most unexpected development in Nigeria, given that the nation had recently portrayed itself as being uninterested in fighting corruption.
According to the chairman of the group, Comrade Moshood Erubami, the conviction by the Lagos High Court has opened a new chapter of realisation by the judiciary, that corruption is a cankerworm that needs to be checked if Nigeria's dream to develop is to be realised.
The conviction of a big fish like Bode George is a testimony that the EFCC under Mrs. Waziri, is succeeding in its resolve to restore national integrity and ensure that Nigeria has the best performing economy, he said.
Continuing, the TMG official said, "It is akin to a judicial resolve to join efforts and work with Nigeria to start righting the wrongs which had been the bane of our greatness; a good sign that those who have the responsibility to hold fraudsters accountable have woken up from their profound slumber to challenge the oligarch-like financial and economic criminals. It is a clear warning that the day of reckoning is here and that never again shall the law be misused to tolerate mere legal academics to truncate and upstage the real intent of its practice at the expense of the victims of corruption."
ReplyDeleteThe TMG noted the efforts of the federal government to advance the struggle against graft impunity in Nigeria by unwavering support for the most productive anti-graft agency - the EFCC. We only hope the independence granted to the judiciary will be tapped by the judicial operators in not exercising any restraint during this period of emergency to rupture the foundation of corruption and impunity in the country."
The Conference of Nigerian Political Parties (CNPP) appealed to other judges to expedite action on cases relating to graft before them. According to Osita Okechukwu, the publicity secretary of the Coalition of Political Parties, "We hold corruption responsible for those who died because of bad roads, lack of electricity and those who suffered strokes because their companies closed down, or relocated to neighbouring countries resulting in gross unemployment and general decadence in the system in the midst of an unprecedented oil windfall."
Also, the Yoruba socio-cultural group, Afenifere Renewal Group, toed the line of those who deplored the sentence, saying it was not commensurate with the crime committed. According to Yinka Odumakin, the national publicity Secretary of the group, "When public office is abused, the entire system is assaulted. This must not be treated with kid gloves, if the quality of service in our public life is to be achieved to an appreciable standard of the civilised world."
Kid Gloves
Speaking of kid gloves, many Nigerians have expressed disappointment with the judgement. They are of the view that a 30-month jail term is too light for the kind of crime Chief Bode George and his colleagues committed. "The angst is justified considering lesser offences have been visited with grave punishments. "He stated that a few days ago an official of the Lagos state Management Authority was sentenced to four years imprisonment for collecting a bribe of N10,000.
Publicity secretary, Action Congress (AC), Lagos State, Mr. Joe Igbokwe said, "Bode George deserves more than two years imprisonment for stealing billions from the common patrimony, to serve as a lesson to other looters. Now, all those clowns who follow George to court in uniform, will go and find something useful to do for a living."
Former governor of Kaduna State, Alhaji Balarabe Musa, stated emphatically that George deserved more than two years imprisonment, since he had stolen billions of naira.
"He was found guilty of stealing billions, how can that be justified with the two years jail term? It is a jurisdiction of rascality. Let this be a message to all who stole public funds that they may not get away with it," he said.
National Convener, United Action for Democracy (UAD), Comrade Biodun Aremu hailed the judge for doing a good job, saying that "I hope that this will apply to other thieves. Let Bode George pay the price. He looted the treasury and he should pay for this. We wish him a better tenure in jail.
"This conviction is good, as it has shown that the anti-corruption war now has a victim, unlike in the past. Beyond this, all corrupt people hanging around the corridor, of power should be brought to book," he concluded.
Victory For Rule Of Law
ReplyDeleteWhile most respondents have condemned the light sentence, it is nonetheless a victory for the rule of law. As one of the point on the seven point development agenda of President Yar'Adua, adherence to and respect for the for the rule of law and due process is one area where the Bode George case marks a victory for once for Nigeria. Under the administration of former President Obasanjo, a mentor to Bode George, the rule of law was observed more in the breach. It would have been near impossible for the judiciary to do what it did were Obasanjo still in the saddle. It would appear that President Yar'Adua has made a difference. The question is though, for how long?
If the rule of law has emerged a winner, it is not so for the ruling party, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP). While the case lasted, hundreds of the party members, presumed to be loyalists and supporters of Bode George, were always in the court, ready to disrupt proceedings and abusive to journalists. Discerning Nigerians began to wonder whether these people actually knew what was at stake. The questions asked by analysts are how can a people whose patrimony has been toyed with, still show solidarity and loyalty to those who do not care for their future? Is it a reflection of the nature of Nigerian politics, or politics in the PDP? Does the party in power encourage corruption?
While members of opposition parties who spoke to Leadership Weekend all unanimously labelled the PDP a corrupt political party that eulogises and rewards the corrupt, a top PDP member who pleaded anonymity opined that the party is neither corrupt nor rewards the corrupt, and that the so-called PDP members who shed tears when Bode George and his fellow travellers were jailed could indeed be his loyalists. The PDP member said that in view of the high level of poverty and lack of opportunity for many in Nigeria, it is expected that those who have benefitted from Bode George one way or another should identify with him, even in moments of travail. He said further that under Yar'Adua, any PDP member found guilty of corruption in a properly constituted court, would have himself to blame.
For the EFCC, it is a job well done, as stated already by its former chairman, Nuhu Ribadu. At last, the anti-graft agency can claim that at least one 'big' person has been nailed as a result of its effort and determination. The present chairperson, Farida Waziri, has also scored an important victory that will put her critics in check.
All said, Nigerians, as usual, will look forward to more of the Bode George type of case, where the guilty are actually punished, no matter how symbolic.
By Chioma Gabriel, Deputy Editor and Ebun Babalola
ReplyDeleteSince 2008 , Chief Bode George, the one-time deputy national chairman of the ruling Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, South West zone was charged by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission ,EFCC, for inflation of contracts to the tune of N84 billion with five other board members.
The offence was said to be committed during his tenure as the Chairman of the NPA board between 2000 and 2003.
Various evidences given during the trial by the committee set up to investigate the allegation of fraud leveled against the accused persons revealed that there were irregularities in the award of contract by the Board of the NPA between 2001 and 2003.
Contracts were revealed to have been split and inflated by the Board and advance payments above the 25 per cent limit approved by the government made in the award of fifteen contracts.
Chief Bode George and the five other former board members which included Aminu Dabo, O. Abidoye, Abdullahi Tafida, Zanna Maidaribe and Sule Aliyu first appeared before the state High Court on a 163_count charge on August 9, 2008.
They were alleged to have, among others, conspired about June 6, 2003 to inflate the contract price for the rehabilitation of Kalmar Container Handler from 215,555.52 Euro to 269,965.71 Euro.
Alhaji Balarabe Musa and Chief Ayo Adebanjo
Also, they were alleged to have inflated contracts awarded to Dateks Ltd for the replacement and installation of six 11KVA High Tension Panels with accessories at Sub-station C, Tin Can Island Port, Lagos, from 310,500.40 Euro to 345,925.00 Euro.
But last Monday, ,Bode George was convicted by Justice Olubunmi Oyewole of the Lagos High Court. alongside four other former board members of the NPA to two years each on a seven-count charge and another six months each on a 28-count charge.
The seven-count charge included abuse of office, while the 28-count charge was on wilful disobedience to lawful authority.
Since his conviction, Nigerians have continued to react to the sentence and in these encounters, more Nigerians speak on the Bode George scandal.
This should help the cause of anti-corruption — Adegbite
Dr Lateef Adegbite is the Secretary- General of Supreme Council of Islamic Affairs and he says:
I hope the judgement on Bode George will enable the judiciary to speed up the processes of trials for others facing similar accusations. There are many unresolved issues pending in the courts , even the latest banks scandal.
The pace of trial is scandalously slow and we hope this breakthrough on the Bode George case will help the cause for anti-corruption.
It’s triumph of the rule of law-Akinfenwa — Senator Mojisoluwa
Akinfenwa is the national chairman of Alliance for Democracy:
Well, I understand that
Bode George has appealed the judgement that sent him to jail. If the appeal goes through, that is the essence of democracy and if it doesn’t, he will serve his jail-term and that is the triumph of the rule of law. If he is still guilty after the appeal, he will serve his term. It’s still the triumph of democracy and the rule of law.
Two years is too small for the offence committed - Adebanjo
Chief Ayo Adebanjo is a Lagos-based lawyer and a chieftain of pan-Yoruba organisation, Afenifere. He was one of the strong voices of the National Democratic Coalition, NADECO, during the years of the struggle for democracy:
The rule of law has taken its course and the judge has let justice triumphed. But if you want my personal view, I will say that the jail-term of two years is too small. It should have been more but I believe the judgement is according to what the law permits.
Until people who are corrupt get punishment, we will not make any meaning from the war against corruption.
This should also serve as a lesson to all public servants who think that by their appointments, they have been invited to ‘come and chop’. This is a lesson. No evil doer can go scot-free. After looting the public treasury, the day of reckoning still comes.
ReplyDeleteWe should deal with looters as robbers—Ayo Fasanmi
Senator Ayo Fasanmi is a factional leader of the pan Yoruba group Afenifere:
The judgement shows that if we have succeeded in rigging elections in Nigeria, we have not succeeded in rigging justice. The judgement on Bode George will serve as a deterrent to others and it also reveals that there is so much corruption in our public life.
What people call the dividends democracy is actually dividends of corruption. There is so much corruption in our national life and something has to be done. The course of justice also has to be quickened because justice delayed is justice denied.
People who committed offences should be dealt with. Those who loot the treasury or steal public funds should be dealt with in the same manner armed robbers are dealt with and as a matter of fact, the two-years jail term given Bode George and his accomplices is inadequate for the offence they committed. That’s the way I see it.
Two years jail-term such a scandal — Balarabe Musa
Bode George
Alhaji Balarabe Musa is a one-time Governor of old Kaduna state and commentator on national issues:
First of all, I think the judgement is a judicial scandal, because, how can anybody justify the punishment of two yeas to someone who has been found guilty of having stolen N85 billion, even if the money was shared with five others.
How can that be? A person like this should get execution and if it is not provided for, should go to prison for life because the action of stealing such an amount of money has cost the loss of lives of hundreds or even thousands of people. What is a mere two years?
Two years is a mere cool off and afterwards, they would go and enjoy the stolen billions and then, someone like George will still have a chance to become a national leader . It’s such a scandal and it can happen only in Nigeria where thieves are ruling the country.
Now, to other Nigerians, the situation has shown that it’s not really all those who are looting the country that are getting punished but only those who have lost out in the power game. And the majority of those responsible to this level of corruption that we are in will get away with it because their colleagues are in power.
The judiciary is not serious with anti-corruption war—Tanko Yakassai
ReplyDeleteAlhaji Tanko Yakassai is an elder statesman and first republic super civil servant:
This is the time to appeal to all public officers to be careful and stop looting the funds put under their care.
This development also shows that the looting of treasury in Nigeria is becoming too much. There are some cases involving ministers and top officials of government that we don’t even hear about anymore. Some of these cases have been going on for years and nobody is hearing anything about them anymore.
The people involved are walking about free on the streets and nobody has heard that the cases have been disposed of. We know about the former Education minister who gave bribe to the Senate then and the case is dead now but we didn’t hear it was struck off by the court.
There are so many cases like that some of which involved senators, permanent secretaries and other top people. Whenever they get to the courts, they die.
I think it is high time that the judiciary joins the band-wagon of anti-corruption pro-actively. I wouldn’t want to say whether two years is okay for Bode George or not but at least, he has been convicted for stealing. And this is just one case in a million. What about the other cases of corruption in court? What happened to them?
Why do leaders of this country steal and get away with it?
Anti-graft is used against political opponents— Abubakar Audu
I have no comment because the people who established the anti-graft body and the politicians are enemies.
The purpose of the establishment is to use it against their political opponents but it would boomerang.
We’ve advised him to wash in Ijaw water — Comrade Joseph Evah
The likes of Bode George are very hard. He married my twin sister and because of that, we have been trying to manage his behaviour but he refused.
We have advised him to go and wash in the Ijaw water but he refused. What happened to him will serve as a lesson to those who are involved in such criminal acts.
30 months in jail is too light for such a crime — Yinka Odumakin
After a long lull of warfare without tell-tales, the anti-graft war in Nigeria recorded major casualties on Monday with the conviction of former deputy-National Chairman of the Peoples Democratic Party ,PDP , Commodore Olabode George and his five accomplices.
In a moment of bold and courageous judicial pronouncement, Justice Olubunmi Oyewole passed a guilty verdict on George, the former Chairman of the Nigerian Ports Authorities (NPA) alongside Aminu Dabo, O. Abidoye, Abdullahi Tafida, Zanna Maidaribe and Sule Aliyu; and sentenced them to two years each on the seven-count charges of abuse of office and six months each for the other 27-count charge of disobedience to constituted authority.
The six convicts are to spend the next 30 months in Kirikiri prison for their criminal conducts during their stewardship at the Nigerian Ports Authority under the administration of Gen. Olusegun Obasanjo whose name has also featured in various financial scandals but is yet to be brought to the temple of justice.
For a country suffused in moral decadence in public office where criminals have become celebrities and protection of corrupt people from justice has become a direct policy of state, the jailing of George by the judge has brought some catharsis albeit with cautious praise for the judiciary.
Afenifere Renewal Group (ARG) joins millions of Nigerians to laud Justice Olubunmi Oyewole for his diligent judgment where he stated inter alia “When public office is abused, the entire system is assaulted. This must not be treated with kid gloves, if the quality of service in our public life is to be attained to an appreciable standard of the civilized world”.
It is on the matter of “kid gloves” that many Nigerians have expressed disappointment with the judgment. They are of the view that 30 months in jail is too light for the kind of crimes Bode George and his colleagues committed.
ReplyDeleteThe angst is justified considering the fact that poor people who committed lesser offences have been visited with grave punishments. A few months ago, an official of the Lagos State Transport Management Authority (LASTMA) was sentenced to four years imprisonment for collecting a bribe of N10,000. It is the same that some poor folks lost their arms to Sharia judgments while one of the Governors who promulgated the Sharia law and has been charged to court for stealing N17billion in one day is now sitting on the Anti-Corruption Committee of the Senate.
It is quite appropriate to point out that another source of pessimism by our people is that for one Bode George and five accomplices who have just been sent to prison, there are hundreds of Bode Georges and thousands of accomplices who stroll in and out of the Villa, who are chief launchers at different occasions, who give public lectures about, who are splashed on the covers of soft-sell journals with all their frivolities and even serving in the present government at all levels.
We shall only take the anti-graft war serious if many more of such people are brought to book and quite expeditiously too. That it has taken roughly 14 months to conclude the trial of George and cohorts shows clearly that corruption charges can be done with if the will is there.
ARG is equally worried like many of our compatriots that the verdict on George and co was silent on the acquisitions from the proceeds of these financial crimes. That may pervert the idea that they could still as much as possible, spend a few months behind bars and return to enjoy their loots. These were the same issue we raised when Lucky Igbinedion was fined N3.5million in a plea bargain without a full disclosure of what he forfeited.
The standard should be that once you are convicted of looting public funds, you should automatically forfeit to the state all the proceeds of such crime.
It would be incomplete if we fail to comment on the shameful conduct of PDP elements who stormed the Lagos High Court in assorted aso ebi to celebrate corruption with Bode George and even had the temerity to assault journalists who were doing their lawful duty. It becomes sickening reading the South west chairman of the PDP Alhaji Tajudeen Oladipo even castigating the judiciary as he told a national daily ,”We in the PDP reject the judgment in its entirety.
How can somebody be jailed without an option of fine? We believe that Bode George is not guilty of the charges preferred against him”. Didn’t their BOT chairman, Gen. Olusegun Obasanjo, declare a while ago that nothing embarrasses him? It is a pity that the Yoruba nation has also fallen under the rule of greedy dogs who don’t understand shame.
ReplyDeleteThere are sacred cows in the ongoing fight against corruption — Gbenga Soloki
The Committee for the Defence of Human Rights (CDHR) has commended the ruling of Lagos High Court and indeed the Nigerian Judiciary over the various charges on the NPA scam involving the former PDP boss – Chief Olabode George and others over the multi-million naira scam, describing the decision as ‘restoration of hope and confidence in the Nigerian judiciary’.
The group equally stated that the imprisonment of the former PDP Chieftain and others involved in the scam has shown that there is no ‘sacred cow’ in the ongoing fight against corruption and consequences befalling offenders. Indeed this clears the seemingly atmosphere of lost of hope in the rule of law and the lost of confidence in the hard-earned democratic rule in Nigeria.
The CDHR therefore urged the Yar’Adua -led government to stop at nothing in prosecuting and punishing other office holders whether incumbent or former who used their offices to enrich themselves.